Understanding Index Fund Returns & Tracking Error

Index funds or index mutual funds have become a core part of our modern investing approaches because of what they offer: transparency. These passive funds aim is to simply to replicate the performance of a chosen benchmark index as closely as possible. 

It must be noted that when investors compare their index fund returns with the benchmark index, they often notice some small gaps. Sometimes, the fund might be lagging slightly or it may feel closer and occasionally the difference may seem larger than expected. Now, such gaps raise a natural question within all investors: If an index fund is simply just supposed to copy the index, why do the returns never look exactly the same?

The answer for this lies in understanding how index fund returns actually work, and how “tracking error” quietly influences the outcome over time in passive index investing.
 

What Is Tracking Error and Fund Returns in the Context of Index Funds?

Index funds have a mandate to follow a benchmark index such as the Nifty 50 or the Nifty 500 and aim to replicate its movement as closely as possible.

Due to this structure, index fund returns are always evaluated relative to the index. A 9% return may look fine on its own, but if the index delivered 8.5%, the conversation immediately shifts to why the difference exists. Tracking error enters the picture here, not as a flaw, but as a measure of how closely the fund stays aligned with the benchmark over time.

Tracking error helps investors ask a more relevant question: Did the fund track the benchmark index as an index mutual fund should?

Index Fund Returns Explained

At its core, an index fund exists to match the benchmark, and not to beat it. This sounds simple at first, but it does place a criteria on how the fund operates. The portfolio must mirror the index composition at all times. Changes in the index must be reflected promptly. 

Realistically, an index fund’s return is rarely exactly identical to the index return because of various factors. Apart from operational costs, factors such as execution timing, rebalancing logistics, market liquidity, and fund processes create a gap between index returns and fund returns. As a result, investors should expect index fund returns to be slightly lower than the index. For example, if an index delivers a 10% return over a year, an index fund tracking it may deliver 9.8% after expenses. This shortfall is not a flaw, but the price of accessing the market in a clean, regulated, diversified format. 

Tracking Error vs. Tracking Difference

These two terms are often used interchangeably, which leads to confusion among many investors.

Tracking difference is the easier of the two to understand. It is simply the gap between the fund’s return and the index return over a given period. Say, if the index returns 10% and the index fund returns 9.8%, the tracking difference is 0.2%. This number is visible, measurable, and easy to compare across funds.

Tracking error, however, tells a subtler story. It looks at how that difference behaves over time. Instead of focusing on where the fund ended up, it focuses on how it moved along the way. Measured as the standard deviation of daily or weekly return differences, tracking error captures the consistency of replication. A fund may finish the year close to the index but still show high tracking error if its returns frequently drifted away and then corrected themselves.

For investors, a predictable tracking builds confidence, while erratic tracking, even if it evens out eventually, introduces uncertainty.

Key Factors Causing Tracking Error

Tracking error does not come from one single flaw. It builds up quietly from how a fund operates day to day.

•    Expenses: Any index fund involves management expenses that slightly reduce investor returns. Even low-cost funds cannot avoid these entirely.
•    Cash Holdings: An index fund doesn’t remain 100% invested at all times, it maintains a percentage of cash to manage redemptions or pending investments. Return over this cash does not move in line with the index, hence even a low holding of cash can create temporary deviations.
•    Portfolio Realignment: Indices are updated periodically in the market. When constituents are added or removed during such changes, the fund must buy or sell securities to realign the portfolios in the same manner. During such times, trading in any low liquidity stocks may lead to a difference in prices or timing.

Why It Matters

•    Low Tracking Error: Low tracking error means a consistent replication of the index by the fund across different market phases. For investors, this means closer returns after deducting routine costs.
•    High Tracking Error: High tracking error indicates uneven index replication and lowers reliability as a passive fund.

In Essence

Index funds are designed for simplicity. One of the most important factors which explains their effectiveness is how closely and reliably they follow the benchmark index over time.

Tracking error helps investors evaluate this reliability. For investors, understanding this distinction shifts the focus away from short-term performance comparisons and toward structural quality. Over long periods, this consistency is what allows index funds to serve as dependable building blocks in a portfolio.

For NSE disclaimer refer SID.
Disclaimer: This document represents the views of Axis Asset Management Co. Ltd. and must not be taken as the basis for an investment decision. Neither Axis Mutual Fund, Axis Mutual Fund Trustee Limited nor Axis Asset Management Company Limited, its Directors or associates shall be liable for any damages including lost revenue or lost profits that may arise from the use of the information contained herein. No representation or warranty is made as to the accuracy, completeness or fairness of the information and opinions contained herein. The material is prepared for general communication and should not be treated as research report. The data used in this material is obtained by Axis AMC from the sources which it considers reliable.

While utmost care has been exercised while preparing this document, Axis AMC does not warrant the completeness or accuracy of the information and disclaims all liabilities, losses and damages arising out of the use of this information. Investors are requested to consult their financial, tax and other advisors before taking any investment decision(s). The AMC reserves the right to make modifications and alterations to this statement as may be required from time to time.

Axis Bank Ltd, is not liable or responsible for any loss or shortfall resulting from the operation of the scheme.

Mutual Fund Investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.